Follow us

The Supreme Court has today ruled on the ranking of certain pension liabilities when issued to companies in administration or liquidation.

In a decision that will have significant consequences for lenders to groups of companies that have a defined benefit pension scheme, the ability to restructure such groups, and the rescue culture in general, the Supreme Court overturned earlier decisions of the High Court and Court of Appeal, finding that a Financial Support Direction or Contribution Notice issued by the Pensions Regulator against a company after it had gone into administration or liquidation will not have priority ranking as an expense of the insolvency proceedings and will instead rank as a provable debt.

Herbert Smith Freehills partners Kevin Pullen and Stephen Gale, assisted by Gawain Moore and Aoife Gannon and Pensions partner Roderick Morton, advised the Nortel Administrators on their successful appeal in this case.

For a link to the judgment, please click here.

For the full background to the case and details and comments on the judgment, please click here.

Related categories

Key contacts

Karen Anderson photo

Karen Anderson

Consultant, London

Karen Anderson
Susannah Cogman photo

Susannah Cogman

Partner, London

Susannah Cogman
Elizabeth Head photo

Elizabeth Head

Of Counsel, London

Elizabeth Head
Hannah Cassidy photo

Hannah Cassidy

Partner, Head of Financial Services Regulatory, Asia, Hong Kong

Hannah Cassidy
Clive Cunningham photo

Clive Cunningham

Partner, London

Clive Cunningham
Marina Reason photo

Marina Reason

Partner, London

Marina Reason
Kelesi Blundell photo

Kelesi Blundell

Partner, London

Kelesi Blundell
Jenny Stainsby photo

Jenny Stainsby

Global Head – Financial Services Regulatory, London

Jenny Stainsby
Hywel Jenkins photo

Hywel Jenkins

Partner, London

Hywel Jenkins
Chris Ninan photo

Chris Ninan

Partner, London

Chris Ninan
Jon Ford photo

Jon Ford

Partner, London

Jon Ford
Valerie Tao photo

Valerie Tao

Professional Support Lawyer, Hong Kong

Valerie Tao
Cat Dankos photo

Cat Dankos

Regulatory Consultant, London

Cat Dankos
Patricia Horton photo

Patricia Horton

Professional Support Lawyer, London

Patricia Horton