Follow us

Employers may have a legitimate aim in wishing to prohibit discussion of religious views on homosexuality in the workplace, but should ensure the prohibition is communicated and applied consistently, and can be justified.

In Mbuyi v Newpark Childcare (Shepherds Bush), a nursery was found to have directly and indirectly discriminated against a Christian employee dismissed for answering a question from a lesbian colleague about her beliefs concerning homosexuality. The tribunal concluded that the employer's procedural failings were motivated by stereotypical assumptions about evangelical Christians, amounting to direct discrimination. In relation to indirect discrimination, the tribunal ruled that, although there was a legitimate aim for prohibiting employees from expressing negative views about homosexuality, namely to provide the nursery service in a non-discriminatory way, the employer had failed to establish that dismissal was a proportionate means of achieving this. This was because of the lack of prior warning and the inconsistency in failing to address the part the lesbian colleague had played in starting the inappropriate workplace discussion.

Employers may have a legitimate aim in wishing to prohibit discussion of religious views on homosexuality in the workplace, but should ensure the prohibition is communicated and applied consistently, and can be justified.

Key contacts

Samantha Brown photo

Samantha Brown

Managing Partner of EPI (West), London

Samantha Brown
Steve Bell photo

Steve Bell

Managing Partner - Employment, Industrial Relations and Safety (Australia, Asia), Melbourne

Steve Bell
Emma Rohsler photo

Emma Rohsler

Regional Head of Practice (EMEA) - Employment Pensions and Incentives, Paris

Emma Rohsler
Andrew Taggart photo

Andrew Taggart

Partner, London

Andrew Taggart
Fatim Jumabhoy photo

Fatim Jumabhoy

Managing Partner, Singapore, Singapore

Fatim Jumabhoy
Barbara Roth photo

Barbara Roth

Partner, New York

Barbara Roth