Follow us

HR practitioners and in-house counsel have often had to think about mutual separations as a way to 'exit' employees. This month, we take a look at some frequently-asked questions in Singapore, Hong Kong, Japan, China, Indonesia and Thailand.

Country

Are employer-initiated mutual separations common?

What payments are typically made in a mutual separation?
Singapore

No, save in redundancy situations or where the employee is a senior one and there is a negotiated exit.

  • an ex gratia payment
  • payment in lieu of notice (if required)
  • payment of accrued but untaken annual leave
  • pro-rated payment of an Annual Wage Supplement, where the employee has a contractual entitlement
Hong Kong

Not as common as in some other jurisdictions (like Indonesia or Japan), where it is more difficult to terminate unilaterally. However, we often see mutual separations initiated in redundancy situations or for negotiated exits.

  • an ex gratia payment
  • payment in lieu of notice (if required)
  • payment of accrued but untaken annual leave
  • pro-rated payment of any 'end of year payments', where the employee has a contractual entitlement
  • severance or long service payments, where the employee has a statutory entitlement
Indonesia

Yes, as otherwise the employer will need to obtain a court order before it is able to terminate employment.

  • depending on the circumstances, payment of either the standard or enhanced statutory severance package (comprising of a severance payment, a service payment and compensation pay)
  • an ex gratia payment can also be made
China

Yes, employer-initiated mutual separations are relatively common.

  • an ex gratia payment
  • payment of accrued but untaken annual leave (which must be paid out a special rates)
  • severance, where the employee has a statutory entitlement
Thailand

No. Mutual separations are usually only initiated in redundancy situations.

  • an ex gratia payment
  • payment in lieu of notice (if required
  • payment of accrued but untaken annual leave
  • severance, where the employee has a statutory entitlement
  • all other contractual entitlements
Japan

Yes, as it is usually very difficult for an employer to terminate employment in Japan.

  • an ex gratia payment
  • payment in lieu of notice (if required)
  • depending on the employer's work rules, payment of a retirement allowance

For more information, please contact Fatim Jumabhoy at fatim.jumabhoy@hsf.com.

Key contacts

Samantha Brown photo

Samantha Brown

Managing Partner of EPI (West), London

Samantha Brown
Steve Bell photo

Steve Bell

Managing Partner - Employment, Industrial Relations and Safety (Australia, Asia), Melbourne

Steve Bell
Emma Rohsler photo

Emma Rohsler

Regional Head of Practice (EMEA) - Employment Pensions and Incentives, Paris

Emma Rohsler
Andrew Taggart photo

Andrew Taggart

Partner, London

Andrew Taggart
Fatim Jumabhoy photo

Fatim Jumabhoy

Managing Partner, Singapore, Singapore

Fatim Jumabhoy
Barbara Roth photo

Barbara Roth

Partner, New York

Barbara Roth